Nursing Homes & Extended Care in Holtsville, NY (2026)

Q: How does Palmelle rank these nursing homes?

Palmelle ranks each facility using a Clarity Score from 0 to 10, blending federal CMS inspection results and state licensing records. The same numbers regulators use.

Q: Can Palmelle help our family pick the right one?

Yes. Help Me Choose is a $199 service. We do the calling. You do the choosing. One named recommendation in 72 hours, money back if we miss the 72-hour promise.

2 licensed nursing homes in Holtsville, NY

Updated October 21, 2026

6.4Solid

Island Nursing and Rehab Center

5537 Expressway Drive North, Holtsville, NY 11742

Island Nursing and Rehab Center brings a 4.0-star CMS rating, strong inspection scores (4.0/5), high quality measure scores (4.0/5), 0.72 RN hours per resident daily, and no federal fines on record. Worth asking: Long-stay antianxiety / sleep medication rate is 30%.

3 flaggedFull record ›

Not yet
scored

CHERYL D. MARTIN

93 BARRETTS AVE, HOLTSVILLE, NY 11742

Full record ›

Not sure where to start?

We do the calling. You do the choosing.

Staying home instead? Our CAPS-certified senior home safety assessment covers fall risk, bathroom safety, transfers, walker access, lighting and thresholds, and ends in a written prioritized plan. We do not sell the construction.

Help Me Choose · $199 Senior Home Safety Assessment · $399 Home Services · From $99

The promise

You get your answer. Or your money back.

No recommendation in three business days? The $199 goes back. No forms.

The Unspoken Authority: Why Your Parent Trusts Their Doctor Over You

The Cover Story

The Conversation

The Unspoken Authority: Why Your Parent Trusts Their Doctor Over You

Understanding the deep-seated deference older adults give medical advice, and how to gently shift the conversation.

By Neil D'Monte & Palmelle Editorial Team · 7 min read

Read the story → All of Perch →

Questions families ask

New York state guide · All the answers, in one place

Common questions

How many licensed nursing homes are in Holtsville, NY?

2 licensed nursing homes in Holtsville, NY, drawn from federal CMS records and state licensing data.

How does Palmelle rank these nursing homes?

Each facility is ranked using a Clarity Score from 0 to 10, blending federal CMS inspection results and state licensing records. The same numbers regulators use.

What is the Palmelle Clarity Score?

A 0 to 10 transparency score built from federal CMS data and state licensing records. It reflects what inspectors found. Not opinions and not advertising.

Can Palmelle help our family pick the right one?

Yes. Help Me Choose is $199. We do the calling. You do the choosing. One named recommendation in 72 hours. Money back if we miss the 72-hour promise.

Nursing Homes & Extended Care in Holtsville, NY.

This is what the inspectors wrote down.